top of page

"The Dolls" Controversy: JaKayla Alston’s Dismissal Sparks Heated Fan Debate

Writer's picture: Brandon WestBrandon West
dianna williams 'the dolls', the dancing dolls, brandon tv
Dianna Williams on 'The Dolls' Episode 15

The latest episodes of The Dolls delivered a bombshell that had fans of the popular reality TV series taking sides and lighting up social media. The controversy unfolded when JaKayla Alston, a member of the Dancing Dolls majorette dance team, was dismissed by Coach Dianna Williams in a heated moment over a seemingly small—but ultimately explosive—issue: her hairstyle.


A now-viral clip from the episode revealed Dianna dismissing JaKayla from the team via a talk with her mother - as not to embarrass her in front of the group - for not adhering to the team's strict hairstyle rules. Coach D made it clear that JaKayla’s thick locs, while beautiful, were deemed unsuitable for competition and parade performances. The scene into an emotional exchange between parents that left fans polarized.


The clip posted to social media let fans join in on the controversial decision.




Team Dianna: Rules Are Rules

Supporters of Dianna Williams rallied behind her decision, emphasizing that the Dancing Dolls have established rules for a reason. Many pointed out that maintaining a uniform appearance is a standard practice in competitive dance teams, ensuring cohesion and professionalism during performances. Plus, the girls themselves voted on the hairstyle.


One fan commented about the safety of having long, thick hair for a dance performance like theirs, as shown below.

dianna williams 'the dolls', the dancing dolls, brandon tv
Imani Lee comments on 'The Dolls' controversy

Others, like Dameatrice Washington, argued that the parents are the real problem.

dianna williams 'the dolls', the dancing dolls, brandon tv
Dameatrice Washington comments on DD4L Controversy

Team JaKayla: Let Them Embrace Their Natural Beauty

On the other side of the debate, fans criticized Dianna’s decision as unnecessarily harsh and insensitive. For many, the issue went beyond team rules—it was about representation and the importance of allowing young Black women to embrace their natural hair, including protective styles like locs.


Fans like Cynthia Lee went as far to call Williams' decision "...some whitewash bs..."

dianna williams 'the dolls', the dancing dolls, brandon tv
Cynthia Lee responds to Dianna Williams decision

Critics of Dianna’s stance also questioned whether the hairstyle rule itself was outdated and unfairly targeted natural Black hairstyles, which deserve to be celebrated, not sidelined.


A Bigger Conversation on The Dolls

The controversy has ignited a larger conversation about the intersection of beauty standards, professionalism, and cultural identity in predominantly Black spaces like Dancing Dolls and majorette dance. Is there a way to balance uniformity and self-expression? Should rules like these evolve to better reflect the diversity of natural hairstyles?


For her part, Dianna Williams has yet to address the backlash directly other than responding to some comments defending her decision, leaving fans eagerly waiting to see how the drama unfolds in future episodes. Will JaKayla’s dismissal lead to a deeper reflection on the team’s rules, or will the standards remain unchanged?

dianna williams, btv, brandon tv, the dolls, dancing dolls
Dianna Williams addresses controversy in the comments of Instagram

One thing is certain: The Dolls continues to bring not just jaw-dropping performances but also thought-provoking debates that resonate far beyond the dance floor. Watch the full episode here.


What’s your take? Should JaKayla have followed the rules, or does the DD4L need to rethink their approach to hairstyles? Let us know your thoughts on social media.


 

bottom of page